Dana Monroe is the primary caretaker for her uncle, who is disabled. Several years ago, her uncleโs health worsened and doctors decided to amputate one of his legs. Her uncleโs bedroom, however, was not on the ground floor.
โAt that time, he had to go up and down steps,โ Monroe said. โHis credit is awesome, but because Iโm his caregiver, finding somewhere for him to live was hard. I had to find a private owner, so it was an older house.โ
The familyโs housing options were limited, because Monroe was convicted of a drug-related felony in 2007.
โIโve had to fight for housing,โ Monroe said. โSince I came home in 2009 โ I had one child at the time โ I havenโt been able to get any housing assistance, or any government assistance.โ
The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development always denies federal housing assistance to two narrow groups: people who have previously manufactured methamphetamine in assisted housing and people on a lifetime sex offenders list. In addition, HUD allows housing providers to exclude applicants who have been convicted of drug-related, violent, or other crimes that might threaten resident welfare โ within a recommended look-back period of five years.
One national study of 261 public housing authorities found that roughly half either did not define a look-back period or considered records that were more than five years old.
For the past four years, Monroe has rented from a friend of the family, who is now hoping to sell his property. This has pushed Monroe back into the private housing application process.
โIt has been extremely hard โ and expensive with housing fees, and nobody gives those back!โ Monroe laughs. โ$75 a person, $50 a person. Do I get $25 back if I donโt qualify? Because it didnโt cost you $75 to run my credit.โ
Monroe likes to present her application in person, because she can distance herself from what real estate agents might imagine from her background check.
โI have three children. I take care of a disabled uncle. I havenโt had any infractions since I was incarcerated. Iโve worked at one place for nine years,โ Monroe said. โThose are my biggest steps to let people know.โ
Monroe said that realty companies accept her application, but when they present it to property owners, she gets turned away.
โThis didnโt work out. Weโll keep looking for you,โ Monroe said, paraphrasing the agents. โBasically, giving me a false hope that itโs not my income and itโs not my credit โ the two things that I worry about the most.โ
This April was the 50th anniversary of the Fair Housing Act, which protects buyers and renters across the United States from discrimination by race, national origin, disability, religion, sex, color, or the presence of children.
โItโs good business practice to practice fair housing because it opens the market up to everybody,โ said Donna Patton, who teaches the educational requirements for the Charlottesville Area Association of Realtors. โI tell people when I teach the class, โWe donโt care about anything other than the fact that we want to make sure they can afford what theyโre looking at.โโ
In 2016, HUD published new guidelines that said โa housing provider violates the Fair Housing Act when the providerโs policy or practice has an unjustified discriminatory effect, even when the provider had no intent to discriminate.โ
Barring housing applicants based on their criminal background, the guidelines argued, was a form of discrimination. Because African-Americans and Hispanics are incarcerated at higher rates than are whites, overbroad criminal history-related bans likely have racially and ethnically discriminatory effects, the guidelines stated.
โYouโre not able to live over here, but thereโs a place over here where people like you โ or, people like her โ or, people like them โ are able to live,โ said Eddie Harris, who mentors formerly incarcerated fathers as part of his work for the nonprofit ReadyKids.
โNow, if thatโs not discriminatory practice, just enlighten me and let me know what it is. Because it sure smells like it. It sure feels like it. And the results are similar.โ
Patton also works as an associate broker with the realty company Keller Williams Alliance. She said she asks for financial information from buyers and that the agents who handle rental properties check credit scores.
โBackground checks?โ Patton said. โThatโs the first Iโve heard of it. I sound a little shocked because I am.โ
Harris said he does not want to lump the many forms of discrimination into one bucket, but he does see how much the barriers can affect his menteesโ lives.
โWhat I try to do is to take the excuses away,โ he said. โIโm unable to be a good father if Iโm not a good man. I canโt be a good man if Iโm not a good human. And I canโt be rehabilitated if I have never been habilitated.โ
When the new HUD guidelines came out, Charlottesvilleโs Public Housing Association of Residents and Legal Aid Justice Center took the opportunity to rethink local public housing policy.
One of the policy ideas, based on public housing in New Orleans, was to use a matrix system to rate the severity of a housing applicantโs criminal background. Qualifying housing applicants would then meet with a screening panel to explain their re-entry efforts.
The current system denies applicants and then allows them to appeal with mitigating circumstances.
โI get maybe two, at most, appeals a year for an admissions decision. I donโt think Iโve ever had people appeal because they were denied for a criminal activity,โ said Brandon Collins, an organizer with PHAR. โItโs all just so subjective.โ
Collins said PHAR and Legal Aid are thinking about bringing the issue back up with the current board of the Charlottesville Redevelopment and Housing Authority.
โI think we currently have a pretty friendly housing authority that understands a lot of this stuff, and they might consider mitigating circumstances more than in the past,โ he said.
โWe do need to talk to residents,โ Collins said. โIโd hate to just hand over our workshop notes to them and a policy and say, โHere, pass this,โ with so much time passed since we last talked.โ
Harris emphasized that such changes would have to occur in the private realm, as well, to transform the lives of ex-offenders.
โYou have a lot of real estate moguls around here in Charlottesville. They own a lot of housing โฆ If the private sector is not on board with these initiatives, they will never win,โ he said.
To one formerly incarcerated woman, who wished to remain anonymous, keeping her child out of trouble means finding the right neighborhood. She likes her current home in Albemarle County, but the apartment complex has raised her rent and she can no longer afford to live there.
โI donโt want to move into the projects,โ she said. โIf you have a distribution charge, they deny you. And honestly, thatโs where I got in trouble, at public housing, so I donโt want to bring my child up in that environment.โ
She was convicted of a drug-related felony in 2010. When she was released four years later, she got a job as a hair stylist within a week. Since then, she has been promoted three times. She attaches employer and landowner references to her housing applications, but she still has had no luck.
โMy unit is very clean. I donโt smoke in my home. I take care of where I live at. Iโm very quiet. I donโt bother nobody,โ she said. โWhen they would show an apartment, they would show my apartment.โ
Although her housing applications also have been rejected, Monroe tries to shield her children from her concerns.
โMy children have never seen a struggle. We have never been homeless. Weโve never had to sleep on anybodyโs sofa, floor, in a car โ none of that,โ Monroe said. โI want my children not to worry about whatโs going on. I want them to worry about school.โ
Recently, however, Monroeโs oldest daughterโs school worries have become financial.
โSchool these days, itโs about shoes, how you look, if your hair is the right way,โ Monroe said. โI do like for you to have nice things, but Iโll buy them on my time, not because you came hollering and screaming. Iโll get it, but you have to wait for me, because I have bills and other things to do.โ
Stories like these motivate Harrisโ work with fathers.
โEach individual, hopefully, has a win in their heart,โ he said. โI think when we diminish that win in a personโs heart, we not only do them a disservice, I think we do our community a disservice. How in the world can we get to where weโre trying to go to, as a society, if we donโt have all hands on deck? Can we afford the luxury of excluding people?โ




