In 2017, when Charlottesville’s City Council agreed to create a new board that would independently review the actions of the Police Department, city leaders and community activists alike had high hopes for it.

They hoped that the Police Civilian Review Board, as it was then called, would have a range of oversight powers. One of the most critical was the ability to independently investigate claims of police misconduct.

Eight years later, we’re not there yet.

Four people dressed professionally sit at a long table. While one person speaks, gesturing with his hand, the other three watch him listening.
Credit: Photo courtesy of The Presidential Precinct, a Charlottesville-based nonprofit.

Charlottesville’s civilian board that oversees police is at a crossroads — unable to independently investigate and unsure what city leaders want it to accomplish

Since the beginning, the local activists that worked to create the Police Civilian Oversight Board, as it is now called, wanted it to investigate allegations of police misconduct. That didn’t become possible until 2021, when the State of Virginia enacted a law giving oversight boards the right of independent investigation.

Charlottesville had a board at that point. Its members responded quickly, drafting a new ordinance that would give it profound investigative power: to receive and conduct independent investigations into citizen complaints, have full access to Police Department reports and records, hold hearings and exercise subpoena power, and make disciplinary recommendations, among other things.

From August 2021: Charlottesville Police Civilian Review Board approves pending ordinance granting powers outlined in new state law, adopts hearing procedures

Almost exactly one year later, the city launched an online portal where residents could submit police misconduct complaints “directly to the Board for investigation.” And the PCOB took on its first case.

Or so we thought.

A view from a police dashboard camera shows an officer standing next to a handcuffed man near a police cruiser. Both have their backs to the camera.
Credit: Zack Wajsgras/Chalottesville Tomorrow

From August 2022: It took five years, but the board of civilians that oversees the Charlottesville Police Department has its first case

That case was never actually reviewed by the PCOB. The Board held a mock hearing, and then the attorney who raised the complaint settled the issue with the Charlottesville Police Department.

Since then, the PCOB has not conducted a single investigation. And, thanks to Anastasiia Carrier’s reporting, we now know this is because the Board can’t. Or, at least, the rules for conducting that investigation are so limiting that it makes no sense to try.

This is laid out in more detail in Ana’s latest story, but the crux of the problem is this: Police officers, as city employees, are not compelled to answer questions asked by the PCOB. And doing so can be detrimental to them. Anything they tell the PCOB can be used in court against them.

“No one in their right mind would voluntarily agree to engage in that type of interview process because they have zero protection,” Inez Gonzalez, the PCOB’s executive director, told Ana.

That basically means the PCOB cannot interview officers. And without the ability to interview officers, it can’t conduct a complete investigation.

So, as it exists now, the PCOB is continuing to collect misconduct complaints at that portal the city launched in August 2022. But, instead of reviewing them, Gonzalez simply forwards them to the Charlottesville Police Department’s office of internal affairs.

That’s one of several issues the Board is navigating right now, and the members are working together with their executive director and the city manager to re-write their bylaws and operating procedures to address them.

We’ll continue following their progress.

Have a great weekend, everyone!
Jessie Higgins, Democracy Editor

Charlottesville Tomorrow is hiring!

As journalists, community leaders, volunteers and passionate readers who believe that local news ecosystems should be strong, we are always looking to connect with people who want to do it better.

As a reporter, I focus on our local democracy and run our annual, essential Voter Guide. If there’s something you think we should be investigating, please get in touch! And you can follow all the work we do by subscribing to our free newsletter!