In a scathing rebuttal, the City of Charlottesville has asked a judge to throw out a lawsuit filed by local residents in January to stop the city from implementing its new zoning ordinance.

“The Plaintiffs already have that which they now seek to deny others — good, affordable housing in a desirable locality,” the city’s response, filed in Charlottesville Circuit Court on March 16, begins. “To do so, the Plaintiffs, having lost at City Council and at the ballot box, seek a judicial veto of the City’s zoning ordinance changes.”

Logo reads "Short & Important"

The suit they were responding to was filed by nine city residents in Charlottesville Circuit Court. It alleges that the city’s new zoning ordinance is “void and otherwise invalid.” The suit makes several allegations, including that the city failed to adequately consider how the new zoning ordinance would impact transportation.

But their key legal arguments is that, in 2021, the City violated state law by sending just the transportation chapter of its comprehensive plan — and not the entire plan — to the Virginia Department of Transportation. For that reason, the suit argues, the comprehensive plan adopted by the City Council in November 2021 is void. And if the comprehensive plan is void, so is the zoning ordinance it is based on, the suit argues.

The city rejected this assertion outright.

“VDOT approved the transportation elements of the 2021 Comprehensive Plan by letter dated November 5, 2021,” the 22-page response reads. “Plaintiffs have concocted technical faults and attempted to impute those purported faults to the City Council.”

The City is seeking a hearing, and to have the case dismissed. City spokesperson Afton Schneider said that the city is working with the plaintiffs’ attorney to schedule a hearing for sometime this spring.

City Council unanimously voted to adopt the zoning ordinance Dec. 1, 2023. It took effect a few weeks ago, on Feb. 19.

While we can’t cover every story that’s important to you, we do our best to be responsive to your needs. We use tips from readers to choose which stories to cover, to incorporate information into broader reports or to help us decide how to grow Charlottesville Tomorrow. Here’s where you can tell us what you think we should be covering.

More local News

I'm Charlottesville Tomorrow's neighborhoods reporter. I’ve never met a stranger and love to listen, so, get in touch with me here. If you’re not already subscribed to our free newsletter, you can do that here, and we’ll let you know when there’s a fresh story for you to read. I’m looking forward to getting to know more of you.